Kill The Indian Save The Man Essay - 1089 Words

After reading Kill the Indian, Save the Man: The Genocidal Impact of American Indian Residential Schools by Ward Churchill, I have come to realization of some matters. First of all, while your goal might had been to civilize the Indians by teaching them English, manners, and change their whole appearance, the outcome was totally different. Your goal might have been successful to you, in the end you got what you wanted: to kill the Indian and Save the Man. But also, you stole those kid’s identities by taking them away from their families. You traumatized them, and making them go through so many forms of abuse. â€Å"Kill the Indian, save the men† or like U.S. Indian Commissioner William A. Jones said in 1903, the goal was to â€Å"exterminate the†¦show more content†¦How do you deal with a trauma that’s not really yours? It’s heartbreaking to see how these communities get up on the aftermath. How some people that went to these boarding schools st ill tear up every time they talk about it. Most communities, or families are broken. Many people turned to substances to drown the bad memories. How many people today still carry depression, anxiety, substance addiction, suicide thoughts, and mental instability. How many Natives did you turned against their own culture? It is sad to see how the language and the culture is declining. For example, let’s take the Navajo’s, not many people speak it anymore. Why? Because of the people that underwent through these boarding schools, they were forbidden to speak in their dialect and forced to learn how to speak English. Causing younger generations to not speak it since parent generations lost the language, and therefore can’t really teach it to their kids. Culture loss, how many people aren’t as traditional as before. All because they had to change their appearance, weren’t allowed to perform any type of prayers or any traditions they had. The population decreased, traditions weren’t practiced by youngsters, and the adults grew old. It’s not many people that went back to their roots after. For example, there aren’t many Navajos that cure, all because the teachings haven’tShow MoreRelatedIndians in Unexpected Places Essay902 Words   |  4 PagesDeloria, with his analytical survey, Indians in Unexpected Places, recounts the synthesis of western white expectations, and American Indians. The book takes its title from the general thesis, which explores not only the relationship between Indians and their introduction into an alien culture, but also the expectations that we have of Indians and how they â€Å"should† interact with our white western culture. According to Deloria, the common no tion is that, â€Å"Indian people, corralled on isolated and impoverishedRead MoreAnalysis Of George Orwell s The Voice Of A Generation 884 Words   |  4 Pagesstyle of writing. Orwell follows the principles of imagery, tone and ethos, meanwhile creating his own rules. Orwell weaves these principles together to write two famous stories that are packed with ethos and told in great detail. Why give a common man more credibility than an emperor? Orwell’s writing style gives him immense credibility because of the sheer detail, vivid color and description. Orwell achieves this through imagery, tone and syntax. Consider Orwell’s use of imagery in Shooting an ElephantRead MoreSherman Alexie s Flight - Flight1686 Words   |  7 PagesResponse Essay: Sherman Alexie Novel Flight Flight is a novel by Sherman Alexie that tell the story of a distressed Native American teenage boy, who has sadly stretched his breaking point after years of ill-treatment at the hands of adults, named Michael but prefers to be called Zits, â€Å"Call me Zits. Everybody calls me Zits. That is not my real name, of course. My real name is not important.† (Zits, p.1). Zits was left to his own devices at the age of six when his mother died of breast cancer andRead MoreNative Americans History1879 Words   |  7 Pagesuncivilized† . Throughout their history American Indians have had the trademark of savagery which has allowed Europeans to isolate, assimilate and mistreat this culture. In result, there has been a phenomenon, in which this paper will discuss as well as the history of savagery in the United States. Already rooted in the Americans and before the arrival of the English empire, the American Indians lived in harmony and peace with their surrounds. The American Indians were skilled farmers and hunters that usedRead MoreThe Elephant as a Symbol for Imperialism in Shooting an Elephant†1188 Words   |  5 Pageslooking like a fool† in front of the crowd (14). At first glance, one would think that it makes sense for him to kill the elephant to save his face, but that was not the case. He effectively uses this incident to demonstrate the â€Å"real nature of imperialism† (3), whereas the elephant represents the British Empire. Orwell was ambivalent about imperialism. At the beginning of his essay, he recalls how Burmese people treated him when he was still working in Burma as a police officer. He was â€Å"hatedRead MoreEssay on The Finale of Evil in Orwells Shooting an Elephant1238 Words   |  5 Pagesâ€Å"Shooting an Elephant,† Orwell faces a dilemma: whether or not to kill the elephant. With his final decision, the elephant finally lays dead in front of thousands of people. He explains that he was forced to shoot it because the Burmese people were expecting him to do that. In addition, he has to do it â€Å"to avoid looking like a fool† (14) in front of the crowd. At first glance, one would think that it makes sense for him to kill the elephant to save his face, but that was not the case. He effectively usesRead MoreSherman Alexie s The Lone Ranger And Tonto Fistfight1362 Words   |  6 PagesFor centuries, Native Americans have struggled to find their identity. This began with the a rrival of explorers and colonists, then peaked with the creation of Indian boarding schools. Schools such as Carlisle, who sought to â€Å"kill the Indian, [and] save the man† (qtd. in Trennert). In these schools Native American children were stripped of their culture, and forced to abide by the white man’s ways. This resulted in generations of Native American who were forced to live between two worlds, withoutRead MoreShooting an Elephant by George Orwell, Brief Description of Words and Symbols872 Words   |  4 Pages1. From the beginning of this essay Orwell’s purpose was never to shoot the elephant. In paragraph 3, lines eight through nine he explains not wanting to shoot it and speaks about bringing the gun to give the elephant a good fright. Leaving the gun at home or bringing the gun would have made no difference to what happened at the end. The gun was of little use, the main gun was not even his own but the riffle. 2. Orwell shot the elephant not to save the people in the village but for his own benefitsRead MoreReaction Paper On Courage Essay1364 Words   |  6 Pagescourage. Throughout this class we have read many books that have characters that show courage. There are themes of courage in The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, To Kill a Mockingbird, the Holocaust Unit, and The Merchant of Venice. The first book I am going to talk about is The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. In this book Junior decides to leave the Rez school and go to Reardan which is a white school. Doing this took a lot of courage. Not many people supported him whenRead MoreAnalysis Of Arthur Miller s The Crucible 908 Words   |  4 PagesJack Del Giudice Mrs. Schmiedeler English 2F 21 October 2015 Crucible Essay â€Å"It takes many good deeds to build a good reputation, and only one bad one to lose it.† This is a quote by Benjamin Franklin and it explains how the puritan society in The Crucible work. this quote shows how fragile a reputation can be, you can spend your whole life increasing your reputation, but one wrong move and it’s completely wrong. In The Crucible, many of Arthur Miller’s characters are very concerned with their reputation